AI commercials are brand adverts made mostly or entirely with generative video tools, and the best-known ones so far have been argued about more than admired. Coca-Cola’s AI holiday adverts of 2024 and 2025 drew loud criticism, McDonald’s Netherlands withdrew one in December 2025, and a low-budget spot for the prediction market Kalshi was shared widely after it ran during the 2025 NBA Finals. The pattern across them is consistent: viewers punish a generated copy of something they loved and tolerate, or enjoy, an idea that could only exist this way.
We make AI commercials for a living, so we have an interest here. We have tried to report the facts as the sources give them, and to keep our opinion in the second half where it belongs.
Which AI commercials does everyone talk about?
| Year | Brand | What it was | How it was received |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Toys R Us | A brand film about founder Charles Lazarus, made with OpenAI’s Sora and shown at Cannes Lions | Mixed. Some praised the novelty, others found it eerie |
| 2024 | Coca-Cola | AI homage to the 1995 “Holidays Are Coming” advert | Widely criticised online as soulless |
| 2025 | Kalshi | A chaotic 30-second spot made with Google’s Veo 3, aired during the NBA Finals | Widely shared, and discussed mostly for how cheaply it was made |
| 2025 | Coca-Cola | A second AI holiday advert, this time with animals | Criticised again, including for continuity errors |
| 2025 | McDonald’s Netherlands | A 45-second AI Christmas advert about festive mishaps | Removed within days |
| 2026 | Svedka | “Shake Your Bots Off”, a mostly AI-generated Super Bowl spot | Restarted the argument about AI and creative jobs |
What happened with the Coca-Cola AI adverts?
In November 2024 Coca-Cola released holiday films that paid homage to its 1995 “Holidays Are Coming” advert, the one with the lit red trucks. NBC News reported that three AI studios made them, Secret Level, Silverside AI and Wild Card, using four generative models. Online reaction called the result “soulless”, and Alex Hirsch, the creator of Gravity Falls, was among the artists who mocked it. Coca-Cola’s statement described the films as “a collaboration of human storytellers and the power of generative AI”.
A year later the company did it again. According to Euronews, the 2025 version was built from more than 70,000 generated clips refined over 30 days, and it swapped human characters for animals. Viewers still found faults, including the wheels of the famous truck. Pratik Thakar, the company’s head of generative AI, was unapologetic: “The genie is out of the bottle.”
There is another side to it. Forrester’s analysis of the 2024 campaign noted that in System1’s consumer testing, viewers who were not told about the AI rated the films close to the top of the scale. The anger was real, but it was concentrated among people who make things for a living and people who loved the original.
What about Toys R Us, McDonald’s, Kalshi and Svedka?
Toys R Us, June 2024. The film premiered at Cannes Lions and was billed in the company’s own announcement as the first brand film made with Sora. It was directed by Nik Kleverov of the agency Native Foreign, and the announcement said it was “almost entirely created with Sora, with some corrective VFX” and an original score. Reviewers were split. Engadget’s review called it a mix of “confusing and eerie” and compared the boy’s hollow manner to a horror-film doll.
McDonald’s Netherlands, December 2025. The advert showed Christmas going wrong to a reworked festive song, and told viewers to hide in McDonald’s until January. NBC News reported that it was made by the agency TBWA\Neboko with the production company The Sweetshop, and that it was taken down within days after viewers called it creepy and cynical. The Sweetshop’s chief executive said the work took “ten people, five weeks, full-time”.
Kalshi, June 2025. A 30-second advert full of deliberately absurd scenes ran during Game 3 of the NBA Finals. eWeek reported that filmmaker PJ Accetturo made it with Veo 3 in two days for about $2,000, and that it took 300 to 400 generations to get 15 usable clips. He then published how he did it.
Svedka, February 2026. The vodka brand brought back its robot mascot for the Super Bowl and, according to TechCrunch, called the result the first “primarily” AI-generated national Super Bowl spot. It was made with Silverside AI over roughly four months, with people writing the storyline.
Why do some AI commercials get mocked?
Our view is that the mockery has three causes, and only one of them is technical.
- Uncanny people. Generated faces hold up for a second and then something slips: a smile that arrives late, eyes that do not settle. The Toys R Us reviews fixed on exactly this. Coca-Cola’s move to animals in 2025 reads to us as a quiet admission that people are the weak point.
- No idea behind the technique. “We made it with AI” is a production note. It cannot carry a film. When the only new thing in a commercial is the tool, viewers judge the tool, and every flaw becomes the story.
- Replacing a beloved original. The 1995 Coca-Cola advert was made by people and is part of many families’ December. Remaking it with a model invites a comparison the new version cannot win, and it reads as a cost saving dressed as magic. The McDonald’s film had a related problem: a cynical message in a season when people want warmth, which no tool would have fixed.
Notice that the Kalshi spot escaped all three. It had no human warmth to fake, the chaos was the idea, and there was no original to spoil.
What makes an AI commercial work?
- An idea that needs AI. The test we use: would this script be impossible, or absurdly expensive, to film? Surreal worlds, scale, places that do not exist and things cameras cannot do all pass. A family at a dinner table does not. If a camera can do it better, choose the shoot.
- Craft in the edit and the sound. Generation gives you raw shots. Rhythm, music, sound design, grade and the decision to cut a shot that is almost right are human work, and they are where a film stops feeling generated. The numbers above make the point: 70,000 clips, 400 generations, five weeks. None of these films was quick to finish well. Our guide to how AI video is made shows where that time goes.
- Honesty about how it was made. Toys R Us, Kalshi’s director and Svedka all said plainly what was generated and what was not. Hiding it is worse, because viewers now look for it, and being caught costs more than being open.
A short checklist before commissioning one
- Can you say the idea in one sentence without mentioning AI?
- Does the script avoid long close-ups of realistic human faces?
- Is there a loved original that viewers will compare it with?
- Who is doing the edit, the music and the mix, and can you hear their past work?
- Will you say publicly how it was made?
- Have the product, logo and packaging been checked frame by frame?
Our view on the Coca-Cola debate
Both camps are partly right. The critics are right that the films were weaker than the original and that a company with that budget had other options. Coca-Cola is right that the tools are not going away. The mistake was the choice of project. Remaking a national treasure is the hardest possible brief for generated video, because nostalgia is precise and the audience knows every frame.
At Zero Shot, an AI video studio in London, our brand commercials start from the opposite end: a script that needs scale or a world no crew could reach, a look approved as still frames before anything moves, and sound and grade finished by people. Our guide to what to expect from an AI video agency in London sets out those stages and what you approve at each one. If a studio will not tell you when a camera is the better tool, read our checklist for choosing an AI video production company.
If you have an idea that might suit this way of working, send us a short brief. We will tell you honestly whether AI is the right tool for it, and give you a fixed price if it is.
Questions people ask
What was the Coca-Cola AI advert controversy?
In November 2024 Coca-Cola released AI-generated films that paid homage to its 1995 'Holidays Are Coming' advert. Critics called them soulless and objected to a company of that size using generated footage in place of artists. Coca-Cola did it again in 2025 with animal characters, and the criticism returned.
Are AI-generated adverts allowed on television?
Yes. AI-generated adverts have already run during the NBA Finals and the Super Bowl. The normal advertising rules still apply, so the advert must not mislead, and broadcasters, platforms and some countries have their own disclosure rules, so check them before a campaign.
Do viewers always dislike AI adverts?
No. The loudest reactions come from social media and from people who work in creative jobs. Forrester reported that Coca-Cola's 2024 films scored highly in consumer testing with viewers who were not told about the AI, so the online reaction and the wider audience do not always agree.
Should a smaller brand make an AI commercial?
It can make sense when the idea would be impossible or too expensive to film and the brand has no famous original to be compared with. It makes less sense when the story depends on real people, real places or real customers.